Wednesday, January 7, 2009

美国最伟大的十部电影

纽约时报文学批评家Stanley Fish评出了美国最伟大的十部电影,这是一家之言,未必包括你我所喜欢的更好的片子,可是那句话怎么说来着:口味问题没法争(you can’t argue about taste.)萝卜青菜,各有所爱。

但此文发表后,在影迷中引起了强烈反响,有兴趣的读者可以去看看上面链接原文后评论。
不知你看过几部,我只看过7与10:

1. The Best Years of Our Lives 黄金时代(1946),directed by William Wyler
2. Sunset Blvd. 日落大道(1950), directed by Billy Wilder
3. Double Indemnity 双重生活(1944), also directed by Billy Wilder
4. Shane 原野奇侠 (1953),directed by George Stevens
5. Red River 红河劫(1948), directed by Howard Hawks
6. Raging Bull 蛮牛(1980), directed by Martin Scorsese.
7. Vertigo 眩晕(1958), directed by Alfred Hitchcock.
8. Groundhog Day 圣烛节 (1993), directed by Harold Ramis;
9. Meet Me in St. Louis 火树银花 (1944), directed by Vincente Minnelli.
10. A Tree Grows in Brooklyn 布鲁克林一棵树(1945), directed by Elia Kazan.

Fish说第一、第二是当之无愧,从3到10排名不分先后

我刚创办的豆列:http://www.douban.com/doulist/203688/

《布鲁克林一棵树》也列在其中,Stanley Fish评价为:这部电影会让你心碎,不是碎一回,而是一碎再碎。你在片中看到一个小女孩对不成器的父亲怀有那样美好的信心;你会看到一个母亲如何在丈夫无能为力的情况下,勉励维持着全家,你会看到母亲产下遗腹子时,母女二人达成的和解。可是心碎之后,我们又能看到它的愈合,因为这个家庭在艰难的世道面前屈服。当然,这是一部煽情片,但是那又怎样?(A tearjerker, to be sure, but so what?)

No comments:

Post a Comment